by The GM on September 25 at 5:47PM
Players come and go each season.  In college, a new kid steps up every year and tries to make everyone forget about the player that they replaced.  In the pros, maybe it is a rookie coming in, or a new free agent that has been labeled as "the man."  Each player has their own story.  Some are the same, some are so different that they seem made up.  I like the story about how Washington Wizards star, Caron Butler, took the second chance that was given to him and turned himself into one of the better players in the league.  I like how Ray Ray McElrathbey has taken in his 12 year old brother and challenged the NCAA for help raising him.  I also like the Colt Brennan story.

brennenhair.jpgSome of you may know that Colt Brennan was enrolled at Colorado and Saddleback Community College before stepping foot on the campus of Hawaii.  Some of you may also know that the reason Brennan didn't last at Colorado was because of a drunken incident his freshman year.

THE PAST
Brennan was accused of sexual assault, burglary, and trespassing.  He was acquitted of the sexual assault charge, but found guilty of trespassing and burglary.  He was then sentenced to 60 hours of community service and 4 years of probation.  He is still on probation while attending school.  With his name pretty much smeared in the mud because of this situation, Brennan had to learn to take the criticism and the scrutiny from others with a smile on his face.  The lesson here was humility.

After a year of staying out of trouble off the field and a good one on it, Hawaii's coach June Jones called Colt Brennan and told him that he could come to Hawaii, with one exception.  That exception was that Brennan would have to pay his way to college for the first year.  If Jones saw that he was staying out of trouble and being a positive member of the football team, then he would grant him a scholarship, but only after that first year was over.

THE PRESENT
This season, Colt Brennan is one of a handful of Heisman Hopefuls.  He was thought to have been a first round draft pick last year, but decided to come back this season to fine-tune his tools for the NFL.  Through three games, Brennan has thrown for 1262 yards, with 16 total (4 rushing) touchdowns and 1 interception.  He sat out the last game against Charleston Southern because of a sprained ankle.  Hawaii is favored to run the table in their conference this season and if that happens, Brennan would definitely be looked upon not only as a great player, but a team leader, something needed to succeed at the next level.

THE FUTURE
I don't know what the future has in store for Colt Brennan, but I do know that he will be drafted next April.  Will he be drafted in the first round?  I don't know, but he will definitely be a first day draft pick.  Will he break NFL records?  I can't answer that, but given the opportunity to play, I think he will be a good quarterback for an NFL team.

THE NUMBERS
A lot of people like to say that Brennan only has success because of the system he plays in.  To me, that is pure garbage.  A system quarterback is one that throws a ton, but isn't always successful.  Brennan is in the top 10 in quarterback rating, yards, completion percentage, yards per attempt, and touchdowns thrown.  He is tied for 12th in completions and tied for 30th in attempts.  Brennan has performed at a high level everywhere he has played.  In high school, he was Matt Leinart's backup and earned three varsity letters.  At Saddleback Community College he led them to the conference championship, was the State Offensive Player of the Year, First Team All-Conference, and was an honorable mention All-American.  If you want to look at a "system quarterback", let's take a look at Brennan's predecessor Timmy Chang.  Chang set an NCAA record for most yards in a career AND for most interceptions in a career as well.  He also had a career completion percentage of 56%, Brennan is sitting at 71% right now.  Just because a quarterback throws for a lot of yards, it does not make them a system quarterback.  If that were the case, the potential number one pick in next year's draft would be a prime example.  Oh, by the way, Brian Brohm is completing less passes than Brennan and is rated lower.

MY TAKE
I like good stories in sports.  Yes, he did break the law.  Yes, he did get punished for it and is still serving his punishment.  No, I don't approve of anyone breaking the law.  Yes, I do feel that second chances should be given in certain cases.  Example:  Rae Carruth should not have had a second chance, and he wasn't given one.  Ray Lewis should have been given a second chance and he got it right.

Colt Brennan, to me, is a person that got it right the second time around.  Whether or not he will be a success in the NFL is still to be seen, but he has succeeded at the college level and I'm anxious to see what he does next.










Comments

[September 25, 2007 7:53 PM]  |  link  |  reply
Royal Hoosier said

He looks like one of the characters from Alien Nation.

[September 25, 2007 9:07 PM]  |  link  |  reply
Jack Cobra said

How many of these guys went on to be successful QB's in the NFL? I think these are most of the categories you talked about.

All-Time NCAA Division 1-A Single Season Records

Passing
PASSING EFFICIENCY * School Year Rating
Shaun King Tulane 1998 183.3
Michael Vick Virginia Tech 1999 180.4
Danny Wuerffel Florida 1995 178.4
Jim McMahon BYU 1980 176.9
Ty Detmer BYU 1989 175.6
* Minimum 15 Attempts Per Game

YARDS GAINED School Year Yards
Ty Detmer BYU 1990 5188
David Klingler Houston 1990 5140
Tim Rattay La Tech 1998 4943
Andre Ware Houston 1989 4699
Jim McMahon BYU 1980 4571

COMPLETIONS School Year Att Comp
Tim Rattay La Tech 1998 559 380
David Klingler Houston 1990 643 374
Andre Ware Houston 1989 578 365
Tim Couch Kentucky 1997 547 363
Ty Detmer BYU 1990 562 361

TOUCHDOWN PASSES School Year TDs
David Klingler Houston 1990 54
Jim McMahon BYU 1980 47
Andre Ware Houston 1989 46
Tim Rattay La Tech 1998 46
David Carr Fresno State 2001 42

[September 25, 2007 9:14 PM]  |  link  |  reply
Jack Cobra said

I'm not saying Brennan isn't a good college quarterback, he is. I'm just saying I doubt his ability to succeed in the NFL.

[September 25, 2007 9:21 PM]  |  link  |  reply
The GM said

But when was the last time there was a "can't miss" quarterback? Ryan Leaf, Tim Couch, Akili Smith, Rick Mirer, Dan McGwire, Kyle Boller, Aaron Rodgers...the list goes on and on. So that is why I don't buy into the "system quarterback" stuff. Peyton Manning was really the last one that I can think of that really was a "can't miss"...and he was one of two that year.

[September 25, 2007 9:41 PM]  |  link  |  reply
The GM said

As to the players you mentioned in their careers:

Tim Rattay: 7th round pick in 2001 and is still in the NFL.

Shaun King: 2nd round pick in 1999 and took Tampa Bay to NFC Championship Game in 2000.

Mike Vick: 1st pick overall in 2001. Three time Pro Bowl selection and set the ALL-TIME rushing record for Quarterbacks.

Ty Detmer: 9th round pick in 1992. Played until 2001.

Jim McMahon: 1st round pick. Played from 1982-1996. Pro Bowler, Super Bowl Quarterback, 18,000 plus passing yards.

I'll give you Ware, Wuerffel, and Klingler. But there are busts at every position that is drafted. I'm sure if you asked any athlete what makes a successful career and I guarantee stats don't come up as often as being in the league or winning.

[September 25, 2007 10:49 PM]  |  link  |  reply
Jack Cobra said

You draft a QB to lead you to championships. Only one man on that list did that....Jimmy Mac.

The 'system quarterback' theory is based on the offense that the team runs and the type of passing plays they have. The QB's decisions are made by the system they are given, not really by themselves in a sense. It's this guy, that guy, that guy, dump it. Manning was the last one, besides Quinn and Leinart off the top of my head, who really was given the freedom to do what he wanted, to pass it to he wanted, how he wanted (for the most part). Brennan isn't doing that. The Hawaii offense is built for the pass with the way the routes are run and the timing of them.

He's very good at what he does. We won't know just how good he is until he gets out of that system and onto something different, ala Rodgers, Losman, Akili Smith, Klingler, etc.

What a QB does when he has to make his own decisions is what sets him apart. That's why you can go with Kurt Warner on a two minute drill with a blitzing defense, or Tom Brady throughout the game, or Peyton Manning 8 days a week.

Quarterback is an extremely difficult position to succeed at in the NFL and very few are able to do it.

Rattay - never played in more than 11 games in a season.

King - the Tampa D took them that far.

Vick - Setting the all-time rushing record for a QB isn't a record most QB's would want.

Detmer - Career back-up

McMahon - Super Bowl Champion. Statistical outlier. Outgoing personality. Wouldn't 'color' in the lines. Grinder.














Site Map | Contact Us | About Us | Advertise With Us